Google Search

Showing posts with label Santorums. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Santorums. Show all posts

Thursday, April 19, 2012

Santorum's Dusted Indigo Period

Of all the amazing statements Rick Santorum made during this year’s presidential race, the one that astonished me the most was one that seemed innocuous.

In a speech in late March before Republicans in suburban Harrisburg, Santorum said that losing his Senate seat in 2006 was a “tremendous gift,” a lesson in humility that he had taken to heart.

“The people of Pennsylvania didn’t always give me what I wanted but they always gave me what I needed,” he said. “And it was a great, in many respects for me, a great gift to get away, to separate out, to get back and involved in the private sector. I had a little distance from Washington to see what was going on.”

Santorum should have felt humbled. He was a two-term incumbent who spent $20 million on his re-election campaign and still lost by nearly 18 points.

To me, one measure of electability is a candidate’s reach outside his party base. The Rick Santorum of 2006 had no reach. He ended up with 41.3 percent of the popular vote, while Republicans in Pennsylvania constituted 40.3 percent of the electorate.

CNN exit polls confirmed the shellacking Santorum took from his Democratic opponent Bob Casey Jr., losing virtually every voter group by wide margins: Democrats, of course, (Casey won 93 percent of the Democratic vote); independents (Casey 73 percent); moderates (65 percent); women (61 percent) and so on and so forth.

Santorum wasn’t defeated by the voters in 2006; he was repudiated. They did not like his politics. They did not like his personality. To put it in terms he might use, they cast him out of the Senate and into the darkness.

If that had happened to me, it would have been a cause of great pain and some soul searching.

An analogous situation is how the United States military reacted after Vietnam. It engaged in a long self-analysis that resulted in transformative changes in strategy, tactics and leadership with the goal of never, ever repeating the mistakes made in that war.

Santorum’s statement implies that in 2006 voters gave him the opportunity to engage in a similar self-analysis: What did he do that he should never repeat? What aspects of his personality could he alter to positive effect? How should his strategy and tactics be changed to improve the outcome?

Handed this “tremendous gift” from the voters, Santorum emerged from the crucible of his 2006 defeat unchanged. He was older, a little thicker around the middle, but in every other aspect he was the same Rick as in 2006. Only instead of playing on the smaller field of Pennsylvania, he decided to go nationwide and run for president.

It was as if the generals in the Pentagon, after reviewing their loss in Vietnam, decided that the best corrective action would be to attack China. That the mistake they made — waging a land war in a small country — could be rectified by waging a land war in a huge country.

Analogies can only take you so far. For Santorum, what made 2012 different was that while he did not change, his audience did. In Pennsylvania, he always appealed to the most conservative of the conservatives, and he did the same in the Republican primaries.

Where we Pennsylvanians saw arrogance, conservative and Tea Party Republicans saw passion. Where we saw rigidity on moral and social issues, they saw rectitude. Where we saw a hard-right politician, they saw a righteous warrior for their cause.

The very attributes and positions that made Santorum anathema to so many Pennsylvania voters in 2006 lifted him into contention in 2012 among a core of activist, angry Republicans.

Among the general electorate, one’s ability to like Santorum tends to be in inverse ratio to one’s exposure to him. The more regular voters saw him, the less they liked him.

When Santorum first announced for president, I thought he would be underestimated as a candidate (which he was) and that he had great potential if he portrayed himself as an economic populist: a man with working-class roots and disdain for the Richie Riches of this world. You know, guys with Harvard M.B.A.’s who worked for private equity investment firms. Not to mention any names.

But that didn’t get his juices flowing. The rights of homosexuals, the morality of abortion and contraception, the evil of Islamofacism, lectures on how moral turpitude had weakened America.  Those were the subjects that got Santorum going.

In this way, he fit Winston Churchill’s definition of a fanatic — someone who can’t change his mind and won’t change the topic.

When I covered the Senate race in 2006, Santorum’s advisers privately rolled their eyes and clucked over this tendency. In public, they just shrugged and called it “Rick being Rick.” In 2006, though, they tried their best to make Rick a little less Rick.

By the summer of that year, Santorum’s numbers against Casey had not improved.  The needle was stuck on a double-digit lead for the Democrat. Something had to be done.  So John Brabender, Santorum’s talented political and media guru, went up with a series of television ads designed to soften his candidate’s image, trying to recast Santorum as a nice guy with centrist instincts. I call this the Dusted Indigo Period of Santorum’s political career.

For these ads, Brabender had Santorum shuck his pin-striped blue suit with red power tie. Instead, he appeared on the screen in khaki slacks and buttoned-down cotton shirts — the kind seen in Eddie Bauer and L.L. Bean catalogs, offered in a palette of solid colors with names like Merlot, Cabin Red, Juniper and Dusted Indigo.

In one, he appeared in a wrestling ring. As huge guys smashed each other in the background, Santorum declared that he deplored the smash-and-whack politics in Washington and that he had reached across the aisle to work with senators such as Joe Lieberman, Barbara Boxer and even (gasp!) Hillary Clinton.

In another, he appeared on the dance floor of a polka party, surrounded by seniors. He smiled as he recounted all that he had done to make sure their Social Security was protected (not mentioning how he supported President Bush’s plan to privatize parts of it.)

In a third, he sat at a kitchen table, shaking his head over how some in the media called him too conservative, while other called him too liberal. “The right thing to call me,” he said, “is passionate about helping the families of Pennsylvania.”

When I saw that last ad, I picked up the phone and called the Santorum campaign. Who, I asked, has ever called Rick Santorum too liberal?

There was someone. An ultra-conservative columnist for the very conservative Pittsburgh Tribune-Review had blasted Santorum for supporting an increase in the minimum wage. ”Santorum, ‘too extreme’?,” the columnist Colin McNickle wrote. “Pshaw! Try too liberal, at least on matters economic.”

The Dusted Indigo ads were clever, smartly done and showed Santorum in his best light.

But they also are an object lesson on the limits of hitting the reset button on your image and political identity. To use a current example, it’s not like an Etch A Sketch. The shadows of the real Rick Santorum remained embedded in voter’s minds. The ads did not work. The needle did not budge. In November 2006, he lost to Casey by a margin of 708,000 votes statewide.

There’s something admirable in Santorum’s consistency. He never temporizes. He remains true to his core values. He is a righteous man. He is also poison politically.

What happened to him in Pennsylvania in 2006 would have happened to him nationally in 2012 had he won the Republican nomination.

Santorum got out of the race at the right moment. He won’t have to worry about winning or losing the Pennsylvania primary. He scores points among Republican leaders for not prolonging the race. He is getting mentioned as a possible candidate in 2016.

From the ashes of his 2006 campaign, Santorum has resurrected his political career. This experience of running for president has been a tremendous gift, too. Once again, he will have an opportunity to learn from his mistakes. Once again, he will not.

When he re-emerges on the political stage, he will be the same as when he exited it. It will be more of “Rick being Rick.”  It’s what he does best.

Tom Ferrick Jr. is senior editor of Metropolis, a Philadelphia news and commentary Web site. He has covered government and politics in Pennsylvania since 1974.


View the original article here

Sunday, April 15, 2012

What Does Santorum's Future Hold?

Although Rick Santorum was exceptionally unlikely to win the Republican presidential nomination, his decision to suspend his campaign, which puts an effective end to the Republican nomination process, is obviously good news for Mitt Romney, who can now focus fully on his general election campaign against President Obama.

Mr. Santorum may have bought himself some goodwill with Republicans by clearing way for Mr. Romney, as polls increasingly revealed that most Republicans considered Mr. Romney’s nomination inevitable and many of them wanted to get the race over with. But is there any way for Mr. Santorum to cash in those chips?

Actually, that might be a challenge; it’s not clear where Mr. Santorum goes next.

Mr. Santorum might have some appeal to Mr. Romney as a vice presidential candidate, since he’s reasonably well vetted and comes from a swing state, Pennsylvania. But Mr. Santorum now has poor favorability ratings with the general public, with an average of 33 percent of voters viewing him favorably and 45 percent unfavorably in surveys conducted since March. As Mr. Romney also has such problems with his favorability ratings, he might be more inclined to pick a fresher face.

If Mr. Romney loses to Mr. Obama, then Mr. Santorum will be mentioned as a front-runner for the 2016 nomination. Mr. Santorum was always playing catch-up in this year’s campaign, having raised little money early on. With more cash, a deeper and more experienced staff, and more support from Republican Party officials, he could have more staying power. He’ll also have more experience under his belt.

It is questionable, however, whether Mr. Santorum can expect the competition in 2016 or 2020 to be as soft as it was this year, with big names like Senator Marco Rubio of Florida, Representative Paul D. Ryan of Wisconsin, former Gov. Jeb Bush of Florida, Gov. Bobby Jindal of Louisiana, Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey and perhaps others looming on the horizon, and as the Republicans who were elected to office in the 2010 wave begin to mature as politicians. Whomever Mr. Romney selects as his vice presidential candidate will also have a good shot at future Republican nominations. Finishing second in a strong field of candidates, as John McCain did in the Republican race of 2000, may be an indication of future success, but it is less of a credential when the competition is middling and some of Mr. Santorum’s support came by virtue of being an “anti-Romney” candidate.

Mr. Santorum could also look to statewide office in Pennsylvania, but that might require a reasonably long wait. The incumbent governor there, Tom Corbett, is a Republican and is eligible for another term in 2014, so Mr. Santorum would either need to mount a primary challenge or hope that Mr. Corbett retires.

Of Pennsylvania’s two incumbent senators, one is a Democrat, Bob Casey, who resoundingly defeated Mr. Santorum in 2006 and who remains fairly popular. Because Mr. Casey is on the ballot again this year and it is too late for Mr. Santorum to challenge him, he would need to wait until 2018 for a rematch. Pennsylvania’s other incumbent senator, Pat Toomey, will be up for election in 2016. But Mr. Toomey is a Republican who is relatively young and who is too conservative to be vulnerable to a primary challenge.

Mr. Santorum is himself fairly young at 53, so he will have plenty of time to build up his brand name and evaluate his options. Still, it could easily be that the 2012 nomination campaign will prove to be the high-water mark of his political career.


View the original article here

Sunday, April 8, 2012

Romney Goes for Santorum’s Jugular in Pennsylvania

WAUKESHA, Wis. — To hear Mitt Romney and his team tell it, Mr. Romney will undoubtedly be the Republican Party’s presidential nominee.

The Election 2012 AppA one-stop destination for the latest political news — from The Times and other top sources. Plus opinion, polls, campaign data and video.

From Stuart Stevens, one of his top strategists: “Mitt Romney is going to be the nominee of the party.”

And from Mr. Romney himself on Sunday: The nominee “will probably be me.”

The question is when. Campaign aides say Mr. Romney’s sweep of primaries on Tuesday in Maryland, the District of Columbia and Wisconsin could buoy him in the next step of the nominating contest — the April 24 contests in Connecticut, Delaware, New York, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island — and help him effectively shut down his chief rival, Rick Santorum, before May.

“The choice is going to be between Mitt Romney and Barack Obama,” Mr. Stevens said.

“The overall dynamic of this race is it’s going to be an M.R.I. of Barack Obama’s record — it’s not an M.R.I. of the soul,” he added, referring to the comment by David Axelrod, the Obama campaign’s chief strategist, that presidential campaigns are M.R.I.’s of the soul.

“This isn’t going to be about dogs or children’s toys or birth control pills,” Mr. Stevens said. “It’s going to be about the overall direction of the country.”

Mr. Santorum represented Pennsylvania in the House and Senate for 16 years, and he has said he needs to win there. A new Quinnipiac University poll of likely Republican primary voters in the state gave him a six-point edge over Mr. Romney, and Mr. Romney’s aides will not publicly predict that he can beat Mr. Santorum there. But the Romney campaign believes that the result in Wisconsin can help propel Mr. Romney to victory in the popular vote in Pennsylvania, delivering a crushing blow to the Santorum campaign. Even without a victory in Pennsylvania’s primary, Mr. Romney’s aides believe he can win more than half of its 72 delegates. The state’s system for awarding them is complicated, but in every district the Romney campaign recruited slates of delegate candidates — with strong name recognition and the support of the state and local party —who either currently support Mr. Romney or are most likely to support him as the party’s nominee at the national convention.

The campaign already has four paid staffers in the state, based in Harrisburg, and others are headed to Pennsylvania as well. Mr. Romney will spend part of Wednesday and Thursday campaigning there.

Though his aides do not expect to let up for the next three weeks, they also plan to use the break to tweak their operation. Until late March, when Mr. Romney spent the weekend at home in La Jolla, Calif., he had spent nearly every day since Christmas on the road, a breakneck pace his aides hope to scale back; Mr. Romney will take three days off for Easter, and try to work slightly shorter days. He will use the extra time, they said, to read and prepare for the general election.

Mr. Romney will also continue to hold more town-hall-style meetings, with their intimate voter interaction, and add more spontaneous stops at restaurants and local establishments. In Wisconsin, for instance, he and Representative Paul D. Ryan stopped by a diner where Mr. Romney picked up four slices of cherry pie, and two days later they popped into a fast-food restaurant famous for its ButterBurgers.

Mr. Romney already seems to have moved past Mr. Santorum and turned his attention to President Obama. In a speech on Friday in Appleton, Wis., he delivered a lyrical, forceful attack on Mr. Obama’s presidency, and on Tuesday he called on Mr. Obama to take responsibility for the nation’s problems.

“He gets full credit or blame for what’s happened in this economy, and what’s happened to gasoline prices under his watch, and what’s happened to our schools, and what’s happened to our military forces,” Mr. Romney said. “All these things are his responsibility while he’s president.”

He added: “It’s time to have someone who will take responsibility, and if I’m president I will not only get things right again, I’ll take responsibility for my errors and make sure that people understand we will have a president in the White House again where the buck will stop at his desk.”


View the original article here

Sunday, March 11, 2012

How Slim Are Gingrich and Santorum's Chances of Catching Romney?

How Slim Are Gingrich and Santorum's Chances of Catching Romney?We all know that if Rick Santorum and Newt Gingrich want to be the Republican presidential nominee, they have to win more states. But they also have to win by large margins, The New York Times' Nate Silver explains, because so many states award delegates proportionally. So while a little gain in Alabama is good news for them, it isn't great. Here's our guide to today's polls and which ones matter.

RELATED: Santorum Wins Tie with Romney in Iowa

Findings: There's essentially a three-way tie in Alabama, with Gingrich with 30 percent of the vote, Santorum with 29 percent, and Romney with 28 percent.
Pollster: Rasmussen
Methodology: Robo-calls to 750 likely Republican voters on March 8.
Why it matters: This poll sharply contradicts one released Thursday by the Alabama Education Association that showed Romney ahead by 10 points in the state, followed by Santorum with 21.6 percent and Gingrich with 21.2 percent. Which should be good news for either of these guys' chances for overtaking Romney, right? Yes. But. It helps to look at Alabama when thinking about how Santorum could come back from Romney's big lead in delegates, given that most of the remaining states award delegates proportionally. As The New York Times' Nate Silver explains, a small win for Santorum in those cases doesn't hurt Romney enough. In Alabama, if the final tally on March 13 is 35 percent for Santorum, followed by Gingrich and Romney tied with about 30 percent, then Santorum gets 21 delegates, while the others get 13 each. But if Santorum wins with 45 percent of the vote to Gingrich's 28 percent and Romney's 19 percent, then Santorum wins 33 delegates to Romney's 1 -- much better. But Silver writes that something pretty huge would have to happen in the race to give Santorum that kind of momentum everywhere. Gingrich, who's only won two states, has even further to go than Santorum.
Caveat: Rasmussen leans right, and there haven't been many polls in Alabama. 

RELATED: Remembering When the GOP Candidates Loved George W. Bush

Findings: Gingrich leads in Mississippi with 35 percent, followed by Romney with 30 percent and Santorum with 20 percent. Mississippi votes March 13.
Pollster: American Research Group
Methodology: Survey of 600 likely Republican voters on March 7 and March 8.
Why it matters: Gingrich's campaign has made it pretty clear he can't go on if he doesn't win the South. His huge lead is party thanks to his popularity among Tea Party supporters, 49 percent of whom say they're voting for him. Santorum is in third place among them with 17 percent, being beaten by Romney, who has 24 percent of Tea Partiers' vote.
Caveat: As explained above, for Santorum or Gingrich to win enough delegates to be the nominee, they have to not just win a lot of states, but crush Romney.

RELATED: GOP Debate: Easy Night for Romney

Findings: 65 percent of adults think the president and Congress can do something to stop gas prices from rising. And 85 percent of Americans think Washington should take immediate action to control gas prices.
Pollster: Gallup
Methodology: Interviews for the tracking poll with about 500 adults on March 5 and March 6.
Why it matters: They are, for the most part, wrong. But it explains why Gingrich -- and Michele Bachmann before him -- is campaigning on a promise to lower gas prices, arguing that gas prices might reach $9 under Obama and that Romney is too rich to understand high gas prices. 
Caveat: This week the national gas price average was $3.79 a gallon. Gallup finds $5.30 a gallon is the point where Americans think they'd have to seriously change their spending habits.


View the original article here